UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY
FACULTY OF LAW
MASTERS OF LAWS
MASTER OF TAXATION
CORPORATE TAXATION
1999 EXAMINATION SEMESTER 2
READING TIME: 20 MINUTES
WRITING TIME: 2 HOURS
CANDIDATES MUST ATTEMPT TWO QUESTIONS. ALL QUESTIONS ARE OF EQUAL VALUE
OPEN BOOK EXAMINATION: CANDIDATES MAY TAKE ANY MATERIALS INTO THE EXAMINATION ROOM
QUESTION 1 (35 marks, 1 hour)
1. Advise on the consequences for company and shareholders in the following situations:
(a) Supermarket Ltd, a listed company, sells goods to shareholders in the company at a 10% discount; it also forgives (up to a maximum of $500 per employee annually) lay-by debts of employees who are shareholders under its employee share acquisition scheme;
(b) Sydney View Courts Ltd is a home-unit company and Ms Jones is a shareholder in the company; under the articles of association of the company, she is entitled to a lease of a flat at a nominal rent designed to cover the company's outgoings; such a lease has been granted to her.
2. The Australian Fund is an unlimited company under the Corporations Law. It is an open ended investment company that raises funds by issuing shares to investors and is managed under a management agreement with another company. Dividends are declared from time to time and under the special article relating to dividends set out below are retained by the Fund for further investment. Investors who require a regular cash return can use a periodic sale of shares privilege whereby a company which is associated with the management company has entered into an agreement with the Fund to purchase or arrange for the purchase of its shares from such shareholders (this company has also agreed to purchase shares generally subject to various conditions).
The articles of association of the Fund provide as follows:
Unless otherwise resolved by the Board all dividends shall be paid by crediting the total amount of dividends due to all members to an account in the books of the Company titled "Members' Dividend Reserve Account" and thereupon the debt due to the members by the declaration of the dividend shall be satisfied. The Members' Dividend Reserve Account shall be part of the reserves of the Company.
In other relevant respects the articles with respect to dividends are in common form. The Fund sends a dividend statement to shareholders each time it uses the procedure set out in the article above.
You are asked to advise on the treatment of both final and interim dividends declared under this procedure and of any subsequent distributions from the Members' Dividend Reserve Account.
3. How may the outcomes in questions 1 to 3 be affected by the Review of Business Taxation?
QUESTION 2 (35 marks, 1 hour)
1. A was the sole beneficial shareholder in a company, X Co Ltd, which was a private company for tax purposes. X Co had accumulated profits and liquid assets. A sold all her shares in the company to B Co Ltd, a public company for tax purposes, during the last year of income for $10,000. X Co in the same year of income, paid a dividend to B Co of $10,000. In the current year of income B Co sold all its shares in X Co to C for $2,000. Consider:
(a) the tax consequences of these transactions for A;
(b) the tax consequences of these transactions for B Co in the last year of income; and
(c) the tax consequences of these transactions for B Co in the current year of income.
2. Consider the following alternative proposals to those of part 1:
(a) after B Co acquires all the issued capital of X Co it causes X Co to issue a special class of Z shares (100 shares) at par; the Z shares are entitled to a $10,000 dividend in priority to all other shares in the company;
(b) a differential dividend article is inserted in the company's articles of association; B Co takes up the 100 Z shares and X Co declares a $10,000 dividend thereon;
(c) the shares in X Co are sold by A not to B Co but to the trustee of the Y Unit Trust being a unit trust specially constituted to acquire the shares and which holds no other assets; B Co takes up all the units in the Y Unit Trust, X Co then issues 100 Z shares to B Co upon which a dividend of $10,000 is paid;
(d) as for (a) except that Z class shares are issued not to B Co but to S Co, a company related to B Co and a public company for tax purposes;
(e) as for (b) except that Z class shares are issued not to B Co but to S Co.
3. A Ltd acquired all the shares in B Pty Ltd in 1990 for $20m. The accounts of B at the time disclosed profit reserves of $15m and share capital of $5m. Since its acquisition the assets of B have either been sold or transferred to other companies owned by A so that all B’s assets are now loans of $25m to other members of the corporate group controlled by A. A wishes to liquidate or otherwise dispose of B but to ensure that it will not suffer any unexpected tax consequences. Advise A especially as to any issues arising for dividend stripping and rebatable dividend adjustments.
4. How may these issues be affected by the Review of Business Taxation?
QUESTION 3 (35 marks, 1 hour)
Hardware Pty Ltd conducts a hardware business in Grafton and has suffered substantial tax losses on both revenue and capital account. It is anticipated that the losses for the current year of income to date are likewise substantial. Hardware also owes money to creditors which it is unable to pay and is owed money by a number of failed companies arising from sales of hardware supplies and loans by Hardware to the companies. Hardware also owns shares in these failed companies. Chainstores Ltd proposes to acquire all the shares in Hardware Pty Ltd and debts owed by it and then to take the following steps:
(1) to change the name of the Company to Chainstores (Grafton) Pty Ltd;
(2) to add new lines to the lines heretofore carried by the company;
(3) to sell on extended instalment sale terms - until now Hardware has sold only for cash or on monthly invoice; and
(4) to arrange with Wholesalers Pty Ltd, a subsidiary of Chainstores Ltd, to provide stock, revenue assets, depreciable assets and capital assets and interest free loans for Hardware at especially advantageous discounts.
Discuss the effect of these proposals on the carry forward losses, the current year losses, allowable deductions for the bad debts and the capital gains/income tax treatment of the shares in the failed companies, assuming that some were acquired in past years and some in the current year of income and that some of the companies concerned went into liquidation just before and just after the change in control of Hardware.
How may these issues be affected by the Review of Business Taxation?